Bridging the Gap: Addressing Digital Equity for BIPOC and First-Generation Students in Higher Education

As the world continues to embrace digitalization, online learning and digital resources are becoming key aspects of the education system. This transition has brought the issue of digital equity to the forefront of our consciousness. This principle, rooted in the belief that every student should have equal access to technology, is gaining relevance in higher education. The focus has shifted from merely acquiring devices or internet connections, to ensuring robust access and the ability to utilize these resources effectively. This shift is critical when considering the overall success of students in higher education, and it becomes even more crucial when examining the experiences of BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, and People of Color) and first-generation students.

The digital divide, the gap in access and ability to use technology, can deeply impact a student’s academic journey. As technology becomes a core part of higher education, students lacking access can face academic difficulties. This issue exacerbates existing socio-economic and racial disparities, a fact made abundantly clear during the pandemic when campuses closed and access to university IT resources became limited. For BIPOC and first-generation students, who often face additional socio-economic challenges, this digital divide can be particularly wide and damaging.

Understanding Digital Equity

Digital equity goes beyond having the hardware and broadband access. It also includes digital literacy, which encompasses the skills necessary to use technology effectively for learning. These skills include being able to find, evaluate, and utilize information online, collaborate digitally, and use software tools for learning and creative expression.

For students, particularly BIPOC and first-generation students, digital literacy skills are crucial for success in nearly all areas of study. Those who lack these skills face a disadvantage, as they may grapple with online coursework, research, and collaboration, creating an additional barrier to their academic achievement.

The Impact on Student Success

The effects of the digital divide on student success are extensive. Research shows that students without adequate access to technology and lacking digital literacy skills are more likely to struggle academically. They may encounter difficulties completing assignments, conducting research, or simply communicating with their professors and classmates.

The impact of the digital divide extends beyond academics, potentially affecting students’ career prospects. In a world where digital skills are increasingly in demand, those without these skills, including many BIPOC and first-generation students, may find themselves disadvantaged when entering the job market.

Promoting Digital Equity in Higher Education

To promote digital equity in higher education, a comprehensive approach is necessary. This approach begins with ensuring that all students, especially BIPOC and first-generation students, have access to the necessary hardware and reliable internet connections. Initiatives such as loaner laptop programs, campus-wide Wi-Fi, and partnerships with local internet providers can help.

However, access alone is insufficient. Colleges and universities also need to invest in digital literacy programs. This could include integrating digital skills into the core curriculum or offering standalone courses and workshops.

Institutions should also monitor digital equity metrics to ensure the effectiveness of their efforts. This could involve surveying students about their access to technology, their comfort with it, or using analytics to identify and support students who are struggling due to digital inequities.

Conclusion

Digital equity in higher education is not just about fairness—it’s an essential part of student success. By ensuring that all students, especially BIPOC and first-generation students, have access to technology and the skills to use it effectively, higher education institutions can help level the playing field.

The pandemic highlighted the urgency of this issue. As our world becomes more digital, the digital divide in education becomes more apparent, and its impact on student success more significant. It’s time for higher education institutions to prioritize digital equity as an integral part of their mission—not just as a response to a crisis, but as a cornerstone of their commitment to fostering student success.

Ensuring digital equity is a collective responsibility. It necessitates action from policymakers, education institutions, and communities. It also requires acknowledging and addressing the unique challenges faced by BIPOC and first-generation students. Together, we can close the digital divide and pave the way for a more equitable, inclusive, and successful future in higher education.

Introducing FSU Libraries eTextbooks Search

Lindsey Wharton, Michael Pritchard, Finley Talley

As we welcome the start of 2021 Summer C, FSU Libraries are proud to announce the launch of our eTextbooks in the Classroom portal!

FSU Libraries’ new eTextbook program identifies currently available eBook titles assigned as required course materials. Instructors and students are able to search by course code, instructor, or book title to see if required course materials are available online through the Libraries. Since its implementation, this project has identified 848 total titles in Spring 2021 and 343 titles in Summer 2021 available through the Libraries’ existing licenses. In these two semesters, the total potential student savings is $1,941,369. 

This initiative was inspired by ongoing student feedback about the high cost of course materials. The Libraries’ eTextbook program builds upon our current Course Reserves service and bolsters advocacy for the program as part of the broader Libraries’ Open & Affordable Textbook Initiative.

Here is a message of support from a student whose textbook was identified as currently licensed by the Libraries:

It’s well known that textbooks can be an onerous additional cost for those pursuing any degree, so it was a welcome and extremely helpful surprise when my professor announced that the library had added an electronic version of the course textbook. This happened two semesters in a row, and the savings across those semesters was close to $200 just for two classes. The ease of access is also a huge benefit that I was very grateful for.

FSU Libraries eResources expand the amount of materials available for higher-level coursework and complements other open educational resources. Furthermore, this program provides a crucial opportunity to support student success by ensuring equitable access to teaching and learning materials. Our eResources work to benefit our FSU community by…

Positively impacting student success & engaged learning

20 out of 28 instructors from studies between 2015 and 2018 reported that learning outcomes improved with open textbooks. FSU Alternative Textbook Grant recipient Vanessa Dennen, Professor of Instructional Systems & Learning Technologies, recently published results from her customized OER project in which students offered positive feedback because the OER were customized to meet their needs and received accurate, relevant, and focused learning materials. This OER and eTextbook integration in the classroom meets these same learning outcomes by providing students and instructors access to paid information that is covered by FSU Libraries.

Ensuring an affordable FSU education for all students regardless of socioeconomic status.

 A ground-breaking study from the University of Georgia found that drop, fail and withdrawal rates (DFW) decreased significantly for low income (Federal Pell Grant Recipients) and part-time students when Open Educational Resources (OER) were used in courses. There was a 53.12% increase in average course grade and a 29.54% decrease in DFW rates for students who were not enrolled full-time. The average final grades of self-identified non-white students in the study were higher with OER and their DFW rates were lower.

Allowing instructors to incorporate perspectives that prepare students to live and work in a diverse and global society.

Open Educational Resources support a diverse community of learners including those with accessibility needs and multicultural perspectives and active student participation with materials. Sixty-four percent of faculty members in studies between 2015 and 2018 reported that using OER facilitated meeting diverse learners’ needs and sixty-eight percent perceived greater student satisfaction with the learning experience when using OER.

We look forward to growing our eTextbook program as part of our larger affordability initiative to reduce barriers to information access and reduce the cost of higher education.

If you are interested in adopting a library-licensed or open eBook to replace your traditional textbook, please reach out to Lindsey Wharton or learn more at our eTextbook Information for Instructors.